diff --git a/docs/seo/LINK-ACQUISITION.md b/docs/seo/LINK-ACQUISITION.md index 9790478..76c3021 100644 --- a/docs/seo/LINK-ACQUISITION.md +++ b/docs/seo/LINK-ACQUISITION.md @@ -10,7 +10,8 @@ external action is recorded here with its status. |---|---|---|---| | 2026-08-22 | awesome-islamic-finance (goww7) | PR goww7/awesome-islamic-finance#2 — Developer Tools & APIs | Open, awaiting owner | | 2026-08-22 | awesome-crypto-trading-bots (botcrypto-io, 2.5k★) | PR botcrypto-io/awesome-crypto-trading-bots#136 — Open source bots | Open, awaiting owner | -| 2026-08-22 | awesome-selfhosted (314k★) | PR awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted-data#2957 — `software/keel.yml`, Money, Budgeting & Management | Open, awaiting review | +| 2026-08-22 | awesome-selfhosted (314k★) | PR awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted-data#2957 — `software/keel.yml`, Money, Budgeting & Management | **Closed by maintainer same day; submitter's account blocked org-wide** — see Lessons | + | 2026-08-22 | awesome-islamic-open-source-apps (tarekeldeeb) | PR tarekeldeeb/awesome-islamic-open-source-apps#7 — Other/Python, TOC count bumped | Open, awaiting owner | | 2026-08-22 | engine repo topics | Added `cryptocurrency` to existing islamic-finance/shariah-compliant/halal set | Done | @@ -19,6 +20,30 @@ PRs by design ("Please do not submit pull requests in this repository") — submissions go through `awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted-data` as a `software/.yml` file. OctoBot's entry was used as the schema template. +## Lessons from the awesome-selfhosted rejection (2026-08-22) + +The data-repo PR was closed by the maintainer (nodiscc) without comment +within the day, and the submitter's account was blocked org-wide — their +standing response to perceived spam. Contributing factors, honestly assessed: + +1. **Retry burst before submission.** The initial (correct) discovery that + the readme repo refuses PRs took several rapid failed PR attempts against + it — failed-attempt bursts from a fresh fork are a classic spam signature. + Rule adopted: on a permission error, stop and investigate; never machine-gun + retries. One submission attempt per organization, ever. +2. **Project maturity.** Their bar is established software; keel is days old + with 3 stars. Even a perfectly-formed submission from a spotless account + would likely have been queued for months or rejected as too new. +3. **No evasion.** The block stands. No alternate accounts, no resubmission + through another identity — that would be exactly the astroturfing this + ledger forbids. If the project earns its place later (stars, releases, + community), the maintainer's public email (nodiscc@gmail.com) is the + honest channel for a polite note from the project author asking whether + a future submission would be welcome. Accept silence or no as the answer. + +The other three submissions are to independent owners (goww7, botcrypto-io, +tarekeldeeb) and are unaffected by this block. + ## Community participation (maintainer's hands, not the site's) Drafts below are ready to post **from the maintainer's own Reddit account**,