[PM seat] domain:skills — 🟢 os-litant · session_01YKEjmbYNvYWJvWGSWx26zK · R1

[huangyiirene]

This post is the single authoritative registration of the skills seat. Four-section template; the job description is versioned at .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/lanes/skills.md — ⛔ not copied here.

Current PM

🟢 os-litant — session session_01YKEjmbYNvYWJvWGSWx26zK, seated 2026-09-10T08:59Z on the maintainer's /pm-dispatch skills summon (fire 2026-09-10T08:49Z), R1 (waves 7–8 in flight). Tier of this session: claude-fable-5-1 (get_session at seating) — skill-face builds and reviews run at tier in seat. Four mutex readings at seating (marker = the comment posted immediately after this revision): latest close brief = os-justin's R9 brief 5615648021; no later round-open marker; newest foreign Claim: on the lane's pm:dispatched ∪ pm:queue cards = #17302's 5614790684 (the signed-off session, older than the brief; no branch pushed after the brief); newest CLOSED lane card #17314's Claim: = the same signed-off session. Charter touch on origin/main 706ad0f: SKILL.md + core-rules 47863f4 (PR #17315, later than the R9 marker) — re-read at seating; lanes/skills.md b110578. Previous incumbents: os-justin session_01MoTv7pn338AZ71owsp19gQ (2026-09-09 → 2026-09-10, R1–R9, brief 5615648021); yinlianghui session_01HxLw5aKDPR5RJgyUR7Exkd (2026-09-09, brief 5598607084). Patrol timer: trig_018qnbhiQ6ghhL69CNL79rJo (check-in 17, fires 21:54Z), re-armed at every check-in.

Maintainer rulings in force (verbatim on their cards, ⛔ not restated): tier policy #17285 → PR #17294 (landed); card-home #17288 → PR #17315 (landed); published PM skill deleted #17311 → PR #17325 (landed); CLAUDE.md pointer program #17161 (3 of 5 repos landed; #17163 cloud / #17165 www wait on repo attachment; #17164 objectos attached this shift); review-of-record #17302 → PR #17349 (MERGED e669e5ee, landing record 5616016907); #17189 ruled (i) by the director with the rider 「17189 同意，但是同时评估是否需要改进skills」 → #17359 (this lane, pm:queue); forced-takeover ruling on #17033 (graded pm:queue p2 and dispatched this shift).

Inherited + running ledger (hand-off)

• In flight (1) + landing (1) — ledger refreshed 2026-09-10T21:18Z (wave 10: [finding] No runnable instrument exists for proving a PR body's closing keywords — closingKeywordRe() is module-private and the parity gate judges parsers, not bodies, so every "prove it two-legged" dispatch this round named an instrument that cannot read a body #17533 into a free slot) (wave 8 rolls: [finding] a gate whose diagnosis is exact but whose REMEDY cannot be carried out from the state it detected — two closed instances, and one gate that carried it at two branches #17037 closed on its measurement; pm sweep: read the last event=schedule run of every scheduled non-blocking workflow and raise a RED one into the label inbox #17132 and [finding] the 域车道 table in pm-dispatch SKILL.md has no entry for docs/qa/**, so checklist-area cards are routed by judgment call #17459 dispatched into the freed slots; PR feat(pm): derive a PR's file list three-dot in check-governed-merges — --pr and --branch #17504 and PR fix(pm): CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER's docblock states a REVIEW tier, not a dispatch mandate #17509 landed 19:11Z; wave 9: [finding] guard-governed-enqueue.sh reads only 'filename' from the changed-files API — a PR that renames a governed file OFF the governed surface reads as NOT governed #17503, Three hand-written sites still document options.stageOrder for a pyramid chart type the schema refuses #17471, [finding] The os-dev dispatch template's {decision_frame} slot is optional and unconditioned, so it is omitted exactly on the rounds that return needs_decision — two independent rounds hit it the same day #17520 and docs(adr): ADR-0131 §1.2(3) calls a precondition "today a refused boot" — nothing refuses it, and #17010 measured the silent boot it describes #17467 into the slots PR docs(pm): add docs/qa/** to the domain:devx row of the lane table #17526, PR feat(pm): mechanise the prior-ruling search for decision cards #17515, PR fix(pm): guard-governed-enqueue reads a rename's old path too #17531 and PR docs(skills): stageOrder is funnel-only at the three hand-written sites #17538 freed), all worktrees /home/user/objectstack-issue-<n>, faces disjoint. In flight: Wave 7: [finding] #15929's class recurred on #16934: a decision card whose Governing text: omitted the ADR that already decides it (ADR-0131 D8) reached batch presentation with a recommendation to re-rule — the text-level governing-text step failed at filing and at presentation; a mechanical prior-ruling search is asked #17009 D1 reported → PR feat(pm): mechanise the prior-ruling search for decision cards #17515 (head cf82b659, new check-prior-rulings.mjs 1268 lines + the four-facet line + wiring; self-test 99; the live drill finds ADR-0131 D8 at rank 1 of 270; GOVERNED; CI green) — REWORK patch round 1 (5623992205): the density payment folds :46's binding into :30 instead of deleting the rule; patch applied in one commit → PR feat(pm): mechanise the prior-ruling search for decision cards #17515 head f4dbf03e re-verified by this seat (:30 folded at 117 B, the Prior rulings read: line 113 B, 50/50; frame-sync / id-lint / --pair exit 0; check-prior-rulings --self-test 99; CI 35 green / 10 skipped) — ACCEPT 5624503629, 速读 5624503942, needs-user-decision, reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong: at the human terminal; on MERGED the card returns to pm:queue for D2. Zone 2(e) falsified: no facet-block presence row exists — D2 is re-graded before dispatch (claim 5622637490, dispatch 5622643752, branch claude/issue-17009-prior-ruling-search) · [finding] A PR's file list taken two-dot feeds check-governed-merges.mjs a SUPERSET — on a branch behind main it can report GOVERNED for paths the PR never touched #17003 → PR feat(pm): derive a PR's file list three-dot in check-governed-merges — --pr and --branch #17504 and pm(dispatch-gates): clause-② prose in dispatch-gates.mjs (docblocks + every --tier printout) and core-rules.md:124 still describes a BUILD-tier mandate once the 强制条款② narrowing lands #16914 → PR fix(pm): CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER's docblock states a REVIEW tier, not a dispatch mandate #17509 landed 19:11:32Z (records below). Wave 8 (from e7e883c1): [finding] The pm-dispatch landing rule lets a dev's auto-merge delete the seat's review entirely — arming on an already-green PR merges immediately #17160 reported → PR docs(pm): record three measured auto-merge and label-cap platform readings #17523 (head 2b204b74, three platform-readings.md rows 108/101/115 B at 425/425, the raise recorded as a ruledRaises entry; candidates 4 / landed 3 / already present 1 — :56–:57 carry the echo reading; GOVERNED; --pair exit 0) — ACCEPT 5623861006, 速读 5623861333, four-piece placed · [finding] references/lanes/engine.md:15 states packages/lint ⇒ domain:devx with no exception — a third text carrying the lane-table mis-read #16993 measured #17088 reported → PR docs(pm): engine lane red line points at the anchoring rule's lint exception #17519 (head 655739ff, lanes/engine.md:15 +1/−1 — the pointer 「packages/lint 的唯一例外见 SKILL.md 锚定规则」, 117 B, 32/32; GOVERNED; --pair exit 0; no fourth carrier found) — ACCEPT 5623644920, 速读 5623645440, four-piece placed. · pm sweep: read the last event=schedule run of every scheduled non-blocking workflow and raise a RED one into the label inbox #17132 (p2 Task) reported → PR feat(pm): read the last event=schedule run of every scheduled non-blocking workflow and raise a RED one into the label inbox (H57) #17543 (head 85922611, check-half-states.mjs +1226 — H57: the latest event=schedule run of every scheduled non-blocking workflow, RED on non-success / stale (widest cron gap + 24 h) / never-ran, one runs-path spelling with the filter + a source audit, population derived from the listing and the local on: blocks, contained failures, band stall; self-test 3213 → 3367 re-run by this seat; NOT governed; --pr exit 0; --pair exit 0; live: 3 objectstack rows and objectui's check-links.yml row) — ACCEPT 5625227990 → every check green at 20:57Z (25 success / 11 skipped) → flipped ready 20:57:33Z → auto-merge (SQUASH passed; the echo said MERGE — the repo's queue method is SQUASH by ruleset) 20:57:49Z after mergeable_state settled → added_to_merge_queue 20:58:30Z (41 s; timeline read); on MERGED: landing record, residue clear, objectui#8402 told, the chain advances to finding(pm-protocol): pm:queue is used for two incompatible things — "triaged and registered" and "ready for a dev" — and the second meaning is the one the card-selection order reads #17417 · [finding] the 域车道 table in pm-dispatch SKILL.md has no entry for docs/qa/**, so checklist-area cards are routed by judgment call #17459 (p3 Task, XS — docs/qa/** ⇒ domain:devx written into SKILL.md's 域车道表, the maintainer's own label action on docs(qa): three approvals-checklist knownGap texts cite the retired backfill-account-issuer.ts #17453 as the authority, paid by density at 812/812; build tier claude-fable-5-1 by the clause-① mandate; governed ⇒ human terminal; claim 5623910237, dispatch 5623911224, branch claude/issue-17459-lane-table-docs-qa-row, from f8e57905) → reported (5624128092) → PR docs(pm): add docs/qa/** to the domain:devx row of the lane table #17526 (head 5d834e00, the docs/qa/** clause in the domain:devx row, 812/812 and widest row 342/342 re-measured by this seat; GOVERNED; --pair exit 0; CI green so far) — REWORK patch round 1 (5624218308): the byte payment dropped the pointer 「按锚定规则例外」 and left the row's spec routing unconditional (a widening of :240's exception); patch = keep the pointer, drop the restated condition 「与 spec 相交面」 (338 B on the 342 pin); patched in one commit → PR docs(pm): add docs/qa/** to the domain:devx row of the lane table #17526 head 42521c38 re-verified by this seat (row byte-equal to the target, 338 B; 812/812; 342 pin; frame-sync / id-lint / --pair exit 0; CI 21 green / 15 skipped / 1 running) — ACCEPT 5624351141, 速读 5624351555, needs-user-decision, reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong: at the human terminal. · [finding] guard-governed-enqueue.sh reads only 'filename' from the changed-files API — a PR that renames a governed file OFF the governed surface reads as NOT governed #17503 (p2 Bug, XS — the pre-enqueue hook's filenames reader emits previous_filename beside filename, plus a rename case pair in the hook selftest; opus; governed .claude/** ⇒ human terminal; claim 5624379837, dispatch 5624380870, branch claude/issue-17503-enqueue-hook-previous-filename, from bea76c92) → reported → PR fix(pm): guard-governed-enqueue reads a rename's old path too #17531 (head cedf38c4, the reader line + renamed_of and a three-assertion rename case; selftest 55/0 on the head, this seat's ablation 53/2 → restored 55/0; the register's two-path answer exit 3 re-run by this seat; GOVERNED; --pair exit 0; CI 12 green / 12 skipped / 4 running) — ACCEPT 5624661319, 速读 5624661662, needs-user-decision, reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong: at the human terminal · [finding] The os-dev dispatch template's {decision_frame} slot is optional and unconditioned, so it is omitted exactly on the rounds that return needs_decision — two independent rounds hit it the same day #17520 (p3 Task, XS — os-dev.md :355's pointer to the deleted rules/dev-template.md replaced by a pointer to the single frame copy, 403/403; build tier claude-fable-5-1 MANDATORY (clause-① file); governed ⇒ human terminal; claim 5624669454, dispatch 5624670387, branch claude/issue-17520-os-dev-frame-pointer, from efa2533d) → reported (5625017711) → PR docs(agents): point os-dev at the surviving decision-frame copy #17540 (head 03b37059, :355 = the seat's candidate verbatim, 112 B, 403/403; ratchet / frame-sync / id-lint / --pair exit 0 re-measured by this seat; CI 12 green / 12 skipped / 4 running) — ACCEPT 5625038596, 速读 5625038886, needs-user-decision, reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong: at the human terminal · Three hand-written sites still document options.stageOrder for a pyramid chart type the schema refuses #17471 (p3 Bug, XS — the three stageOrder sites say funnel only in the parent's two landed statements; dashboards.md at 6089/6090 tokens ⇒ net ≤ +4 bytes paid in-row; the sdui-parser line conditional on check:sdui-lockstep; build tier claude-fable-5-1 MANDATORY (published skills/**); governed ⇒ human terminal; claim 5624518501, dispatch 5624519381, branch claude/issue-17471-stageorder-funnel-only, from efa2533d) → reported (5624952867) → PR docs(skills): stageOrder is funnel-only at the three hand-written sites #17538 (head 6a854fe9, the three sites say funnel only in the parent's two statements + a patch changeset for @objectstack/sdui-parser because the comment reaches the published d.ts; dashboards.md 6090/6090 re-measured by this seat, pyramid hits 0; GOVERNED; --pair exit 0; CI 11 green / 2 skipped / 18 running at ACCEPT) — ACCEPT 5624979313, 速读 5624979660, needs-user-decision, reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong: at the human terminal · docs(adr): ADR-0131 §1.2(3) calls a precondition "today a refused boot" — nothing refuses it, and #17010 measured the silent boot it describes #17467 (p3 Task, XS — ADR-0131 §1.2 item 3 rewritten to the measured truth (reachable; reported at error since PR fix(plugin-auth): report at error when a single-posture deployment holds more than one organization (#17010) #17460; not refused; D5 does not reach it) plus the one clause on §1.2's discount; :558 untouched; opus; governed docs/adr/** ⇒ human terminal; claim 5624989767, dispatch 5624990774, branch claude/issue-17467-adr-0131-refused-boot-premise, from edaf3b2f) → reported (5625183135) → PR docs(adr): ADR-0131 §1.2(3) — the precondition is reachable and reported at boot, not a refused boot #17544 (head 8f7761df, §1.2 item 3 +8/−2, :564 D11 byte-identical to main; ADR links / symbol-anchors / anchors re-run by this seat; GOVERNED; --pair exit 0; CI 22 green / 11 skipped / 1 running) — ACCEPT 5625228300, 速读 5625228599, needs-user-decision, reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong: at the human terminal. · [finding] No runnable instrument exists for proving a PR body's closing keywords — closingKeywordRe() is module-private and the parity gate judges parsers, not bodies, so every "prove it two-legged" dispatch this round named an instrument that cannot read a body #17533 (p3 Task, XS — a --body <FILE|-> mode on scripts/check-closing-keyword-parity.mjs that runs the three parsers loadParsers already builds over one body, exit register documented, self-test with the negation trap as the control; ⛔ no export from check-half-states.mjs, ⛔ no fourth grammar; opus; not governed ⇒ ready → queue after review; claim 5625558465, dispatch 5625559340, branch claude/issue-17533-closing-keyword-body-mode, from 9165d5cd). Landing (0): PR feat(pm): derive a PR's file list three-dot in check-governed-merges — --pr and --branch #17504 and PR fix(pm): CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER's docblock states a REVIEW tier, not a dispatch mandate #17509 went ready 18:45–18:46Z → auto-merge (SQUASH) after mergeability settled → queued 18:46:50Z / 18:47:31Z → MERGED 19:11:32Z as one queue group (1e0d7954, bea76c92; Governed Surface Queue Guard green on both queue heads); records and residue clears done (5624226999, 5624227791). Platform note from PR chore(repo): ignore .worktrees/ so an agent worktree inside the checkout is not untracked #17468's landing: the first enable_pr_auto_merge call 5 s after the flip armed classic auto-merge without enqueuing; the second call, once mergeability had settled, enqueued — platform-readings.md:48 says pass mergeMethod: "SQUASH" explicitly, followed from here on. On each report: review at the contract-review tier per review-checklist.md; gates reconciled with --ran on the final diff.
• Awaiting a human merge (12, governed, four-piece placed on each): PR docs(pm): record three measured auto-merge and label-cap platform readings #17523 ([finding] The pm-dispatch landing rule lets a dev's auto-merge delete the seat's review entirely — arming on an already-green PR merges immediately #17160, head 2b204b74, three platform rows + the ceiling row) · PR docs(pm): engine lane red line points at the anchoring rule's lint exception #17519 ([finding] references/lanes/engine.md:15 states packages/lint ⇒ domain:devx with no exception — a third text carrying the lane-table mis-read #16993 measured #17088, head 655739ff, one lane-file line) · PR docs(skills): state what single posture means for the organization count in objectstack-data #17476 ([finding] The published objectstack-data skill never says what single posture means for the organization count — an AI app author reading it (and the code's exemption list) lands on 「stay single, seed one sys_organization per tenant, bring your own RLS wall」; the sentence that forbids that shape lives only in content/docs/deployment/tenancy-modes.mdx and ADR-0105 §「Today's two postures」, neither linked from the skill #17019, head f301e3ca, skills/objectstack-data states the posture ↔ organization-count contract in three files, token ratchet paid in-region; ACCEPT 5622006852, 速读 5622007272 on the PR; reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong requested by REST, ⛔ not update_pull_request — objectui#6596's incident) · objectos PR 🔗 Broken links detected in documentation #283 ([objectos] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17164, head f5a7cfa6; ACCEPT 5616349432, 速读 5616349067) · PR pm-dispatch: make check-clause2-carriers C4 recognise the live contract-review verdict dialect, and name the session a reviewer writes #17368 ([finding] check-clause2-carriers C4 is silent on every 2026-09-09 contract-review verdict — its VERDICT: discriminator and session-only Reviewed-by: grammar match neither the bold Verdict: heading dialect nor the isolated-subagent authorship the seats now write #17346, head 2afeff04; ACCEPT 5617249216, 速读 5617248824) · PR docs(agents): a PR declaring clause-② grades its changeset at least minor #17415 ([finding] PR #16650 merged with clause-② yes and both packages it grew graded patch — the LEVEL axis could not see them, so it printed green #16973, head 116ccbca, AGENTS.md changeset exception +1 line, ceiling 1075; ACCEPT 5618973214, 速读 5618972882; CI green on the head — 23 success / 15 skipped at 2026-09-10T15:12Z). On MERGED: landing record + residue clear; [objectos] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17164 also verify the cross-repo Fixes closed the card and post program status on [program] CLAUDE.md is a pointer to AGENTS.md in every repo — no second instruction set to maintain (maintainer 2026-09-09) #17161 (4 of 5); [finding] check-clause2-carriers C4 is silent on every 2026-09-09 contract-review verdict — its VERDICT: discriminator and session-only Reviewed-by: grammar match neither the bold Verdict: heading dialect nor the isolated-subagent authorship the seats now write #17346 releases 条款②声明载体是一扇单向门：席位能把自己写进一个自己出不去的状态 —— 一个会话里同一个坑被踩了 5 次 #17366 (check-clause2-carriers.mjs). · PR docs(pm): add docs/qa/** to the domain:devx row of the lane table #17526 ([finding] the 域车道 table in pm-dispatch SKILL.md has no entry for docs/qa/**, so checklist-area cards are routed by judgment call #17459, the docs/qa/** clause in the domain:devx row, 812/812; ACCEPT 5624351141, 速读 5624351555, reviewers requested) · PR feat(pm): mechanise the prior-ruling search for decision cards #17515 ([finding] #15929's class recurred on #16934: a decision card whose Governing text: omitted the ADR that already decides it (ADR-0131 D8) reached batch presentation with a recommendation to re-rule — the text-level governing-text step failed at filing and at presentation; a mechanical prior-ruling search is asked #17009 D1, check-prior-rulings.mjs + the Prior rulings read: line; ACCEPT 5624503629, 速读 5624503942, reviewers requested; the card stays open for D2) · PR fix(pm): guard-governed-enqueue reads a rename's old path too #17531 ([finding] guard-governed-enqueue.sh reads only 'filename' from the changed-files API — a PR that renames a governed file OFF the governed surface reads as NOT governed #17503, the enqueue hook reads previous_filename + the selftest rename pair; ACCEPT 5624661319, 速读 5624661662, reviewers requested) · PR docs(skills): stageOrder is funnel-only at the three hand-written sites #17538 (Three hand-written sites still document options.stageOrder for a pyramid chart type the schema refuses #17471, the three stageOrder sites say funnel only; ACCEPT 5624979313, 速读 5624979660, reviewers requested) · PR docs(agents): point os-dev at the surviving decision-frame copy #17540 ([finding] The os-dev dispatch template's {decision_frame} slot is optional and unconditioned, so it is omitted exactly on the rounds that return needs_decision — two independent rounds hit it the same day #17520, os-dev.md :355 points at the single frame copy; ACCEPT 5625038596, 速读 5625038886, reviewers requested) · PR docs(adr): ADR-0131 §1.2(3) — the precondition is reachable and reported at boot, not a refused boot #17544 (docs(adr): ADR-0131 §1.2(3) calls a precondition "today a refused boot" — nothing refuses it, and #17010 measured the silent boot it describes #17467, ADR-0131 §1.2 item 3 states the measured truth; ACCEPT 5625228300, 速读 5625228599, reviewers requested)
• Closed on a measurement this shift: [finding] a gate whose diagnosis is exact but whose REMEDY cannot be carried out from the state it detected — two closed instances, and one gate that carried it at two branches #17037 (D1 sweep — 172 gates, 752 remedy lines, 0 live unperformable remedies; the card's own shape (3), no rule, no D2; closing reading on the card). Landed this shift (residue cleared on all): through the queue by this seat — PR feat(pm): derive a PR's file list three-dot in check-governed-merges — --pr and --branch #17504 ([finding] A PR's file list taken two-dot feeds check-governed-merges.mjs a SUPERSET — on a branch behind main it can report GOVERNED for paths the PR never touched #17003, check-governed-merges.mjs --pr / --branch three-dot derivations) 1e0d7954 19:11Z (record 5624226999) · PR fix(pm): CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER's docblock states a REVIEW tier, not a dispatch mandate #17509 (pm(dispatch-gates): clause-② prose in dispatch-gates.mjs (docblocks + every --tier printout) and core-rules.md:124 still describes a BUILD-tier mandate once the 强制条款② narrowing lands #16914, the CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER docblock states a review tier) bea76c92 19:11Z (record 5624227791) · PR feat(pm): H4 reads the prose blocker and prints its upstream's state #17494 ([finding] pm:blocked 的封锁被写成散文而非 Blocked-by: #N，解锁扫描读不到 —— 实测三张卡的上游早已关闭却仍挂着，其中一张是 p1 + security #17365, H4 reads the prose blocker and prints its upstream's state; 8 live cards past their unlock surfaced — the triage seat's) 10da5c44 18:44Z (record 5623756222) · PR feat(pm): refuse a merge group whose queued PR still carries needs:contract-review #17484 ([finding] Two clause-② PRs were flipped ready and enqueued while needs:contract-review was still on them (objectui#8723 01:58Z, #16998 02:00Z) — nothing in the merge queue reads the carrier #17040, the queue guard's contract-review carrier leg) 33e07f7c 18:05Z (record 5623305473; promoted cards filed: [finding] three PRs merged on 2026-09-09 still carrying needs:contract-review — no H row names a merged PR or closed card that still wears a gate label #17510 the merged-carrier residue H row as a lane finding, objectui#9018 the port, bare) · PR fix(pm): stop check-widening-tells reading the retirement ledger's own rows as an accept-set gain #17488 (check-widening-tells fires T2 on the retirement ledger's own generated rows, so every retirement's clause-② reading is adverse for the one reason the accept set SHRANK #17300, widening-tells T2 ledger licence + T1 pins) e7e883c1 18:08Z (record 5623306297) · PR chore(repo): ignore .worktrees/ so an agent worktree inside the checkout is not untracked #17468 (.gitignore covers .claude/worktrees/ but not .worktrees/, so an agent worktree created inside the checkout becomes untracked — and the stop hook then asks for git's own plumbing to be committed #17154, .gitignore .worktrees/, ignore-not-prevent) 86458480 17:12Z (record 5622631789) · PR feat(pm): archive the open board before the closed history, and move the snapshot cron off the patrol's hour #17442 (board-snapshot: archive OPEN records first and move the cron off the patrol's minute — the first walk is oldest-first, so the cards a suspension would destroy are archived last, and both workflows spend one per-repo token hour #17434, open-first board walk + cron 7 2,8,14,20) fd62a66b 15:32Z (record 5621313532); acceptance run 34496826690 green 15:40Z — walk_phase: history, open set complete in one run, count check ok 580 = 580, history resuming from the kept February cursor (reading 5621473997): the open board is archived whole from that run on. By os-zhuang — PR pm-dispatch: name the review of record for default-tier lanes, make clearing cite it, and read it in check-clause2-carriers --pair (C6) #17349 (finding(pm-dispatch): after #17285, default-tier lanes have no named "review of record" — five Clause-②: yes merges in one window carry none, and clearing the carrier is indistinguishable from never reviewing #17302) e669e5ee 08:54Z (record 5616016907) · PR skills(pm-dispatch): rank a forced takeover below an in-flight claim #17373 (skills(pm-dispatch): 强制接管抢走「已在处理」的在飞卡 —— 与 SKILL.md:105/489/696 及 seat-post-protocol:31/74 直接冲突，且缺少「在飞子代理报告只回原会话」这一条 #17033) d9b97afd 10:34Z (5617277623) · PR docs(agents): name the missing tool, not an absent sibling scripts/pm/ #17375 ([finding] .claude/agents/os-dev.md states sibling repos have no scripts/pm/ — objectui has one, and a dispatch built on that premise reached a governed file this shift #17244) 8f8dcd29 10:50Z (5617884893) · PR docs(agents): scope the force-push ban to shared branches, with five unshared criteria #17398 (AGENTS.md §3 forbids force-push unconditionally, but check-partof-closing-keyword RULE 2 can only be satisfied by rewriting a commit message — a dev hit both today and had to be told which one wins #16851) cfdd0e95 12:05Z (5618610765) · PR skills(pm-dispatch): the lane table carries non-gate scripts/pm and the three devx paths; lane files point at it #17397 ([finding] The lane table's scripts/ clause covers gates only — a non-gate scripts/** script has no row, scripts/pm/** is stated only in references/lanes/skills.md, and three devx.md:8 paths have none — the successor gap to #17222 #17225) d5125f22 12:07Z (5618610435); through the queue by this seat — PR feat(pm): a scheduled backup of the board, so an account suspension destroys no record #17404 (PM board snapshot: a scheduled workflow archives every issue, comment and PR record to an orphan branch, so an account suspension destroys no record — with a restore recipe #17390, the board-snapshot archiver) 456a0afd 12:48Z (5618976252). First scheduled archive run 13:41Z green (16259758, 852 files, oldest-first — the defect PR feat(pm): archive the open board before the closed history, and move the snapshot cron off the patrol's hour #17442 fixed); archive tip 52bbc3a3 after the acceptance run.
• Blocked this shift: skills: evaluate whether the published security/platform guidance must teach the app-capability vs system-permission distinction and the isDefault → everyone binding rule (after #17189) #17359 → pm:blocked, Blocked-by: #17189 (deliverable 1 accepted as comment 5616225081, ACCEPT 5616301504; deliverable 2 = a +3-line bullet in skills/objectstack-data/rules/security.md, re-dispatch shape pre-written in the ACCEPT; boot-wording correction carried). Three pre-fix readings relayed to An app-declared capability with scope: 'org' counts as a high-privilege bit, so a set carrying only app capability tokens cannot bind to the everyone anchor #17189 (5616302929) for its implementing dev.
• Queue (objectstack pm:queue, this lane) — 20 at this revision ([finding] No runnable instrument exists for proving a PR body's closing keywords — closingKeywordRe() is module-private and the parity gate judges parsers, not bodies, so every "prove it two-legged" dispatch this round named an instrument that cannot read a body #17533 arrived as a lane finding at 20:04Z, graded p3 Task in this fire and dispatched in wave 10). Dispatchable next, by the total order (SKILL.md :458): p2 Tasks finding(pm-protocol): pm:queue is used for two incompatible things — "triaged and registered" and "ready for a dev" — and the second meaning is the one the card-selection order reads #17417 (check-half-states.mjs chain, behind PR of pm sweep: read the last event=schedule run of every scheduled non-blocking workflow and raise a RED one into the label inbox #17132) · [finding] GitHub's PR→issue closing linkage is unreliable in both directions, so a merged PR silently mis-states the state of every issue it mentions #17466 (same chain; home decided: an H row) · [finding] A non-skills lane cannot satisfy the governed fork's at-tier review rule for a PR that touches skills/** — the tier it requires is reserved away from every lane that can hit it #17490 (SKILL.md :610, behind PR docs(pm): add docs/qa/** to the domain:devx row of the lane table #17526) → p3 Bugs [finding] H9's fireability test is a spelling test, so three unfireable Restart-when: shapes pass it green — and #7898 shows H17's trigger index carrying 0 of 11 #17377 (chain) · check-half-states: H22's MEASURED_CLOSED_ISSUE_UPDATES_PER_DAY pin has drifted 2.5x, so every sweep's own coverage sentence is misdescribed by that factor #17254 (chain) → p3 Tasks [finding] label:finding is 2% precise as the "ungraded" index — 385 of 395 open cards carrying it are already graded, on both boards #16904 D1 (behind PR feat(pm): mechanise the prior-ruling search for decision cards #17515) · [finding] The WAIT side of the shared process table is unguarded: pgrep -f matched the asking shell itself, and three background waiters sat deadlocked for 5 hours #17104 (AGENTS.md chain) · [finding] a REST PATCH /pulls/{n} appends a second bare attribution footer — and the measured fix is to send NO footer at all, not to stop re-sending #17239 (behind PR docs(pm): record three measured auto-merge and label-cap platform readings #17523) · [finding] Two triage gradings named a target the governing ADR itself rejects — the grading quotes no line of the adjudication it routes against #17497 (behind PR feat(pm): mechanise the prior-ruling search for decision cards #17515 and the SKILL.md chain) · [finding] three PRs merged on 2026-09-09 still carrying needs:contract-review — no H row names a merged PR or closed card that still wears a gate label #17510 (chain) → unranked skills(pm-dispatch): write the maintainer's base adjudication principle into the four-axis framework — 「以 objectstack 协议为准，文档以实际实现为准」, spec > implementation > documentation #17389 (a maintainer-named card from the director seat, no grade: pm:retriage hung 5625059984 asking the triage seat for priority + type, seat reading p1 Task; SKILL.md chain behind PR docs(pm): add docs/qa/** to the domain:devx row of the lane table #17526 either way; its 「synced copy」 premise is stale — one frame copy since PR chore(skills): delete the published objectstack-pm-dispatch skill and retire every reference that pinned it #17325) · [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163 / [www.objectos.ai] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17165 (repos unattachable). Next free slot ⇒ finding(pm-protocol): pm:queue is used for two incompatible things — "triaged and registered" and "ready for a dev" — and the second meaning is the one the card-selection order reads #17417 / [finding] #15929's class recurred on #16934: a decision card whose Governing text: omitted the ADR that already decides it (ADR-0131 D8) reached batch presentation with a recommendation to re-rule — the text-level governing-text step failed at filing and at presentation; a mechanical prior-ruling search is asked #17009 D2 by their chain positions (both wait on PR of pm sweep: read the last event=schedule run of every scheduled non-blocking workflow and raise a RED one into the label inbox #17132), nothing else is dispatchable: the rest of the queue is serial-held and skills(pm-dispatch): write the maintainer's base adjudication principle into the four-axis framework — 「以 objectstack 协议为准，文档以实际实现为准」, spec > implementation > documentation #17389 waits on its grade and the SKILL.md chain. Serial-held: 条款②声明载体是一扇单向门：席位能把自己写进一个自己出不去的状态 —— 一个会话里同一个坑被踩了 5 次 #17366 · A Claim: comment that yields ZERO parsed branches silently stops governing instead of saying so — #16170's class recurring in a third spelling, now measured on three live cards #17149 · [finding] check-clause2-carriers reads a key-INITIAL describing line as a declaration — its own self-test asserts the general property "only DESCRIBES ⇒ MISSING", and the fixture pinning it covers only the other half #17098 (check-clause2-carriers.mjs, behind PR pm-dispatch: make check-clause2-carriers C4 recognise the live contract-review verdict dialect, and name the session a reviewer writes #17368); AGENTS.md tells agents check:react-declaration-parity cannot run locally and "comes not from CI" — a manifest is checked in at the repo root, so agents record NOT MEASURED where a green is one command away #17405 · AGENTS.md declares the agent commit trailer pair model-free and nothing enforces it — 18 commits on 5 open PR branches carry a model identifier, all with green CI #17280 · [finding] The WAIT side of the shared process table is unguarded: pgrep -f matched the asking shell itself, and three background waiters sat deadlocked for 5 hours #17104 · AGENTS.md Protocol Domains table still lists Cloud | cloud/ after #16325 relocates the directory to marketplace/ #17370 (AGENTS.md, behind PR docs(agents): a PR declaring clause-② grades its changeset at least minor #17415). Held for the maintainer: 共享身份的限流纪律不存在：一次限流信号约束的是「身份」不是「客户端」，而规矩只说了不要重试 —— 2026-09-10 全 fleet 停摆事故 #17374 ([Decision] Fleet writes leave the free user accounts: a GitHub App identity for every seat's GitHub writes (reads stay on user tokens), and no new free accounts #17392). pm:retriage on [finding] The pm-dispatch landing rule lets a dev's auto-merge delete the seat's review entirely — arming on an already-green PR merges immediately #17160 answered by the triage seat (5621657250): p3, platform-readings.md — PR docs(pm): record three measured auto-merge and label-cap platform readings #17523 at the terminal.
• Self-triage this fire (the lane's standing exception, SKILL.md :380 — the triage seat routes domain:skills findings and stops): [finding] The published objectstack-data skill never says what single posture means for the organization count — an AI app author reading it (and the code's exemption list) lands on 「stay single, seed one sys_organization per tenant, bring your own RLS wall」; the sentence that forbids that shape lives only in content/docs/deployment/tenancy-modes.mdx and ADR-0105 §「Today's two postures」, neither linked from the skill #17019 p2 Bug · [finding] Two clause-② PRs were flipped ready and enqueued while needs:contract-review was still on them (objectui#8723 01:58Z, #16998 02:00Z) — nothing in the merge queue reads the carrier #17040 p2 Bug · [finding] pm:blocked 的封锁被写成散文而非 Blocked-by: #N，解锁扫描读不到 —— 实测三张卡的上游早已关闭却仍挂着，其中一张是 p1 + security #17365 p2 Bug · finding(pm-protocol): pm:queue is used for two incompatible things — "triaged and registered" and "ready for a dev" — and the second meaning is the one the card-selection order reads #17417 p2 Task · [finding] #15929's class recurred on #16934: a decision card whose Governing text: omitted the ADR that already decides it (ADR-0131 D8) reached batch presentation with a recommendation to re-rule — the text-level governing-text step failed at filing and at presentation; a mechanical prior-ruling search is asked #17009 p2 Task · [finding] A PR's file list taken two-dot feeds check-governed-merges.mjs a SUPERSET — on a branch behind main it can report GOVERNED for paths the PR never touched #17003 p3 Bug · [finding] H9's fireability test is a spelling test, so three unfireable Restart-when: shapes pass it green — and #7898 shows H17's trigger index carrying 0 of 11 #17377 p3 Bug · [finding] The WAIT side of the shared process table is unguarded: pgrep -f matched the asking shell itself, and three background waiters sat deadlocked for 5 hours #17104 p3 Task · pm(dispatch-gates): clause-② prose in dispatch-gates.mjs (docblocks + every --tier printout) and core-rules.md:124 still describes a BUILD-tier mandate once the 强制条款② narrowing lands #16914 p3 Task · [finding] label:finding is 2% precise as the "ungraded" index — 385 of 395 open cards carrying it are already graded, on both boards #16904 p3 Task; second batch after the triage seat's R+168–R+170 routings: [finding] guard-governed-enqueue.sh reads only 'filename' from the changed-files API — a PR that renames a governed file OFF the governed surface reads as NOT governed #17503 p2 Bug · [finding] A non-skills lane cannot satisfy the governed fork's at-tier review rule for a PR that touches skills/** — the tier it requires is reserved away from every lane that can hit it #17490 p2 Task · [finding] three PRs merged on 2026-09-09 still carrying needs:contract-review — no H row names a merged PR or closed card that still wears a gate label #17510 p3 Task · [finding] The os-dev dispatch template's {decision_frame} slot is optional and unconditioned, so it is omitted exactly on the rounds that return needs_decision — two independent rounds hit it the same day #17520 p3 Task · [finding] Two triage gradings named a target the governing ADR itself rejects — the grading quotes no line of the adjudication it routes against #17497 p3 Task · Three hand-written sites still document options.stageOrder for a pyramid chart type the schema refuses #17471 p3 Bug · docs(adr): ADR-0131 §1.2(3) calls a precondition "today a refused boot" — nothing refuses it, and #17010 measured the silent boot it describes #17467 p3 Task · [finding] No runnable instrument exists for proving a PR body's closing keywords — closingKeywordRe() is module-private and the parity gate judges parsers, not bodies, so every "prove it two-legged" dispatch this round named an instrument that cannot read a body #17533 p3 Task (the last one's lane label was set by the filing domain:cli seat — accepted, ⛔ not re-routed by this seat; its p2 re-graded to p3: the blocking guard already catches the armed auto-close, the instrument buys back the patch round) — grading comments on the cards, finding off, type set; [finding] GitHub's PR→issue closing linkage is unreliable in both directions, so a merged PR silently mis-states the state of every issue it mentions #17466 (filed graded by the triage seat, p2 Task) placed on the check-half-states.mjs chain (5624182977). Ungraded lane findings: 0 (共享身份的限流纪律不存在：一次限流信号约束的是「身份」不是「客户端」，而规矩只说了不要重试 —— 2026-09-10 全 fleet 停摆事故 #17374 wears finding beside its p1 grade — held for the maintainer, not a gap). Interim under [finding] A non-skills lane cannot satisfy the governed fork's at-tier review rule for a PR that touches skills/** — the tier it requires is reserved away from every lane that can hit it #17490: this seat's at-tier review of PR fix(cli): os migrate meta --from N lists the conversions its tombstones prescribe, and an empty range stops reading as success #17462's skills/** hunk is on os migrate meta --from 17 — the invocation the spec 17 tombstones prescribe — reports Nothing to migrate for the conversions it is meant to list, because --to defaults to the current major and the conversions are toMajor: 18 #17134 (5624178424, PASS at tier; check-skills-token-ratchet re-measured 7269/8333 on the head) — the domain:cli seat's four-piece stands. [finding] git add -A over a worktree inside the checkout stages a mode-160000 gitlink at exit 0 with a warning — no repo-side gate refuses a gitlink that has no .gitmodules row #17472 (the gitlink stage) was routed domain:devx by the triage seat. Seat work done and closed this fire: Reclassification worklist: the 7 live pm:awaiting-maintainer carriers entered before the Maintainer-action: line existed — each is read per thread and either given its line or moved to needs-user-decision #17269 (the seven-carrier reclassification — two carriers gone 404, two moved by the director seat's morning repair, two closed; objectui#6596 given its Maintainer-action: line 5621680493, waits on the maintainer adding Governed Surface Queue Guard to the objectui main ruleset's required set; closed completed 5621680868). Earlier this shift: skills(pm-dispatch): 强制接管抢走「已在处理」的在飞卡 —— 与 SKILL.md:105/489/696 及 seat-post-protocol:31/74 直接冲突，且缺少「在飞子代理报告只回原会话」这一条 #17033, [finding] check-clause2-carriers C4 is silent on every 2026-09-09 contract-review verdict — its VERDICT: discriminator and session-only Reviewed-by: grammar match neither the bold Verdict: heading dialect nor the isolated-subagent authorship the seats now write #17346, [finding] .claude/agents/os-dev.md states sibling repos have no scripts/pm/ — objectui has one, and a dispatch built on that premise reached a governed file this shift #17244, [finding] The lane table's scripts/ clause covers gates only — a non-gate scripts/** script has no row, scripts/pm/** is stated only in references/lanes/skills.md, and three devx.md:8 paths have none — the successor gap to #17222 #17225, 条款②声明载体是一扇单向门：席位能把自己写进一个自己出不去的状态 —— 一个会话里同一个坑被踩了 5 次 #17366. The triage seat (session_017VGfRocA8VjczSe84fgjY3, R+166–R+168, seat post [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🟢 os-litant · session_017VGfRocA8VjczSe84fgjY3 · R+166 · (坐席 2026-09-10T12:45Z 维护者召唤;前任 R+165 已留简报,径直坐席) #6015) is held: 代扫 of other lanes' bare cards stopped; none pending.
• Decision box (this lane): 1 — [Decision] Fleet writes leave the free user accounts: a GitHub App identity for every seat's GitHub writes (reads stay on user tokens), and no new free accounts #17392 (filed 10:58Z from the maintainer's 共享身份的限流纪律不存在：一次限流信号约束的是「身份」不是「客户端」，而规矩只说了不要重试 —— 2026-09-10 全 fleet 停摆事故 #17374 discussion: fleet writes move to a GitHub App identity, options A/B/C with the four-facet block and 速读; recommends A; awaits one word). Awaiting the maintainer's 「改」 before filing (raised in the session chat this shift, from their docs(adr-0053): name driver-memory's analytics face in slice 5's implementation map #17380 question): the ADR-routing rows of SKILL.md's domain table — ADR decision text → the spec seat, implementation-map rows → the subject lane. [finding] PR #16650 merged with clause-② yes and both packages it grew graded patch — the LEVEL axis could not see them, so it printed green #16973 and AGENTS.md §3 forbids force-push unconditionally, but check-partof-closing-keyword RULE 2 can only be satisfied by rewriting a commit message — a dev hit both today and had to be told which one wins #16851 were ruled by the director (batch 🔗 Broken links detected in documentation #111, 10:31Z). pm:awaiting-maintainer: [Decision] 22 pure-objectui defect cards live in objectstack under repo:objectui, but objectui IS reachable — the seam fallback is being used where its precondition does not hold #17250. Holds with a fireable condition: [PM decision] skills lane batch 9 — platform-readings.md third increment: raise the ceiling by the measured +39 (358 → 397); and the MCP write-pool quota sentence collision #15275 · [finding] A contract-review PASS leaves ZERO trace on the PR itself — verdict on the card, label cleared, no review object — so a legitimate un-park is indistinguishable from an intruder from the PR side #13417 · [finding] MCP search_issues DID honour GitHub qualifiers (repo: is: label:) in two exact readings — the ledger's "qualifier form returns total_count 0" rule needs a second session before it stands or falls #16762 · [Decision] The shared GitHub identity's GraphQL quota is being burned to 2× — MCP writes go through GraphQL, so seats are silently write-blocked while reads keep working #11742. Blocked: hotcrm has no half-state patrol anchor, so the pm:dispatched + assignee residue after a Fixes auto-close has now been repaired by hand seven rounds running #14881 (os-steve). Anchors left to owners: PM corpus audit (maintainer-directed): classify every instruction line — keep / duplicate / demote / delete — then rewrite and re-lock every ratchet #13597 (zhuangjianguo) · Published-skills factual sweep: verify every behavioral claim in skills/** against the implementation — program anchor #13658 (pm:epic) · Skills catalog optimization program (maintainer-directed): audit every skill on both roots, then optimize — program anchor #14292 · [program] CLAUDE.md is a pointer to AGENTS.md in every repo — no second instruction set to maintain (maintainer 2026-09-09) #17161 (program, tracking, never dispatched).
• Maintainer items pending (asked by the previous seat, unanswered at seating): the six repo:hotcrm cards living in objectstack ([seam → hotcrm] Enumerate hotcrm's authored sys_user_position seed rows whose position names no sys_position catalog row — the unreachable precondition of #16712's ruled refusal #17247 hotcrm #1586 step-3 table: annotate the security-owd-alias row with its intake scope — the rule is alive but unreachable on a defineStack-authored app (measured in #16109) #16519 [repo:hotcrm] Install the half-state patrol in hotcrm — workflow copy, anchor issue, repository variable (hotcrm half of the ruled 纳入) #15009 hotcrm: carry the wall-clock unit of the case SLA matrix in identifiers and one test, collapse the four prose warnings to one (app half of objectstack#13801, mechanism B) #14482 Reading request for the hotcrm seat: does any objectstack-ai/hotcrm writer set sys_activity.environment_id? (#13433 cannot proceed without it) #14362 hotcrm: the six screen-flow dialogs become visible to os lint once the CLI's flow/screen i18n bucket lands — translate them or record the debt #11617 — transfer vs recreate); squash setting D (squash_merge_commit_message → PR_BODY, ruled on [Decision] A commit-trailer red is unclearable by any permitted act, and the gate's own repair requires a MANUAL merge the lane forbids — which rule yields? #16502 batch 🔗 Broken links detected in documentation #73) — once applied, file the skills card retiring RULE 2 of check-partof-closing-keyword and closing [Decision] A commit-trailer red is unclearable by any permitted act, and the gate's own repair requires a MANUAL merge the lane forbids — which rule yields? #16502 / AGENTS.md §3 forbids force-push unconditionally, but check-partof-closing-keyword RULE 2 can only be satisfied by rewriting a commit message — a dev hit both today and had to be told which one wins #16851; attaching cloud / www for [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163 / [www.objectos.ai] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17165; hotcrm#1819.
• Governed-merge audit (R1 window, run 10:35Z on fresh mirrors): objectstack 14 mainline commits from 706ad0f, 2 governed merges — PR pm-dispatch: name the review of record for default-tier lanes, make clearing cite it, and read it in check-clause2-carriers --pair (C6) #17349 e669e5ee and PR skills(pm-dispatch): rank a forced takeover below an in-flight claim #17373 d9b97afd, both merged_by os-zhuang, both this seat's reviewed PRs; since then (unaudited by the script yet, read from the PR objects): PR docs(agents): name the missing tool, not an absent sibling scripts/pm/ #17375 8f8dcd29, PR docs(agents): scope the force-push ban to shared branches, with five unshared criteria #17398 cfdd0e95, PR skills(pm-dispatch): the lane table carries non-gate scripts/pm and the three devx paths; lane files point at it #17397 d5125f22, all os-zhuang, all this seat's; PR feat(pm): a scheduled backup of the board, so an account suspension destroys no record #17404 456a0afd and PR feat(pm): archive the open board before the closed history, and move the snapshot cron off the patrol's hour #17442 fd62a66b not governed (queue landings by this seat, Governed Surface Guard green on both queue heads) — re-run the script at round close; objectui 9 commits from aeaa0f64, 0 governed; objectos 0 commits; cloud / hotcrm UNAUDITED (no checkout) ⇒ INCOMPLETE. Next: --since-ref objectstack=eb7406ca2571 --since-ref objectui=72bcd7783a47 --since-ref objectos=6505ac104c5b (+ hotcrm e855562efac4 when attached).
• Half-state anchor [Half-state patrol] check-half-states live sweep — generated view (please pin) #9857 (last sweep before seating) rows naming this lane: H38 on this post (stale against the 07:27Z claim on finding(pm-dispatch): after #17285, default-tier lanes have no named "review of record" — five Clause-②: yes merges in one window carry none, and clearing the carrier is indistinguishable from never reviewing #17302 — remedied by the R9 close refresh and by this revision); H40 dangling #17044 / #17032 in a historical marker comment (typos in a reading, recorded, left as is). No H row names finding(pm-dispatch): after #17285, default-tier lanes have no named "review of record" — five Clause-②: yes merges in one window carry none, and clearing the carrier is indistinguishable from never reviewing #17302 or PR pm-dispatch: name the review of record for default-tier lanes, make clearing cite it, and read it in check-clause2-carriers --pair (C6) #17349.
• Carried from R9's change-report (three classes, ids in brief 5615648021): 平台事实 — post-stamped.mjs live; GET /search/issues 403 to the repo-scoped token; Actions job-log download unreachable from the container. 原则错/缺 — skills(pm-dispatch): 强制接管抢走「已在处理」的在飞卡 —— 与 SKILL.md:105/489/696 及 seat-post-protocol:31/74 直接冲突，且缺少「在飞子代理报告只回原会话」这一条 #17033; the review-of-record gap closes when PR pm-dispatch: name the review of record for default-tier lanes, make clearing cite it, and read it in check-clause2-carriers --pair (C6) #17349 merges. 可机械化 — none new.

Hot-file serial queue

• AGENTS.md (1074/1074 → 1075 on PR docs(agents): a PR declaring clause-② grades its changeset at least minor #17415's head): PR docs(agents): a PR declaring clause-② grades its changeset at least minor #17415 at the human terminal (the changeset paragraph :1041–:1044). scripts/pm/check-skill-line-ratchet.mjs CEILINGS map: PR docs(agents): a PR declaring clause-② grades its changeset at least minor #17415 (the AGENTS.md row).
• .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md (812/812): PR docs(pm): add docs/qa/** to the domain:devx row of the lane table #17526 ([finding] the 域车道 table in pm-dispatch SKILL.md has no entry for docs/qa/**, so checklist-area cards are routed by judgment call #17459) at the human terminal (the docs/qa/** clause) → [finding] A non-skills lane cannot satisfy the governed fork's at-tier review rule for a PR that touches skills/** — the tier it requires is reserved away from every lane that can hit it #17490 (:610, the tier conjunction) → [finding] Two triage gradings named a target the governing ADR itself rejects — the grading quotes no line of the adjudication it routes against #17497 (the triage grading's governing line, also behind PR feat(pm): mechanise the prior-ruling search for decision cards #17515) → the RULE 2 retirement card once setting D is applied → the ADR-routing row card once the maintainer says 「改」; [finding] The pm-dispatch landing rule lets a dev's auto-merge delete the seat's review entirely — arming on an already-green PR merges immediately #17160 leaves this file if the retriage answer holds. references/lanes/skills.md (33/33), references/lanes/devx.md (36/36): free; references/lanes/engine.md (32/32): PR docs(pm): engine lane red line points at the anchoring rule's lint exception #17519 ([finding] references/lanes/engine.md:15 states packages/lint ⇒ domain:devx with no exception — a third text carrying the lane-table mis-read #16993 measured #17088) at the human terminal. references/decision-analysis.md: [finding] #15929's class recurred on #16934: a decision card whose Governing text: omitted the ADR that already decides it (ADR-0131 D8) reached batch presentation with a recommendation to re-rule — the text-level governing-text step failed at filing and at presentation; a mechanical prior-ruling search is asked #17009 D1 (the Prior rulings read: line).
• scripts/pm/check-clause2-carriers.mjs + references/contract-review.md (60/60): PR pm-dispatch: make check-clause2-carriers C4 recognise the live contract-review verdict dialect, and name the session a reviewer writes #17368 at the human terminal (row C4, :35–:37) → 条款②声明载体是一扇单向门：席位能把自己写进一个自己出不去的状态 —— 一个会话里同一个坑被踩了 5 次 #17366 (the declaration one-way door) → A Claim: comment that yields ZERO parsed branches silently stops governing instead of saying so — #16170's class recurring in a third spelling, now measured on three live cards #17149 (zero-branch claim is malformed, not absent) → [finding] check-clause2-carriers reads a key-INITIAL describing line as a declaration — its own self-test asserts the general property "only DESCRIBES ⇒ MISSING", and the fixture pinning it covers only the other half #17098. scripts/pm/board-snapshot.mjs + .github/workflows/board-snapshot.yml: landed fd62a66b; free. scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs chain (fold-or-serial answered on [finding] pm:blocked 的封锁被写成散文而非 Blocked-by: #N，解锁扫描读不到 —— 实测三张卡的上游早已关闭却仍挂着，其中一张是 p1 + security #17365, gate ① fails): [finding] pm:blocked 的封锁被写成散文而非 Blocked-by: #N，解锁扫描读不到 —— 实测三张卡的上游早已关闭却仍挂着，其中一张是 p1 + security #17365 landed 10da5c44 → PR feat(pm): read the last event=schedule run of every scheduled non-blocking workflow and raise a RED one into the label inbox (H57) #17543 (pm sweep: read the last event=schedule run of every scheduled non-blocking workflow and raise a RED one into the label inbox #17132) landing → finding(pm-protocol): pm:queue is used for two incompatible things — "triaged and registered" and "ready for a dev" — and the second meaning is the one the card-selection order reads #17417 → [finding] GitHub's PR→issue closing linkage is unreliable in both directions, so a merged PR silently mis-states the state of every issue it mentions #17466 → [finding] H9's fireability test is a spelling test, so three unfireable Restart-when: shapes pass it green — and #7898 shows H17's trigger index carrying 0 of 11 #17377 → check-half-states: H22's MEASURED_CLOSED_ISSUE_UPDATES_PER_DAY pin has drifted 2.5x, so every sweep's own coverage sentence is misdescribed by that factor #17254 → [finding] #15929's class recurred on #16934: a decision card whose Governing text: omitted the ADR that already decides it (ADR-0131 D8) reached batch presentation with a recommendation to re-rule — the text-level governing-text step failed at filing and at presentation; a mechanical prior-ruling search is asked #17009 D2 → [finding] label:finding is 2% precise as the "ungraded" index — 385 of 395 open cards carrying it are already graded, on both boards #16904 D2 → [finding] three PRs merged on 2026-09-09 still carrying needs:contract-review — no H row names a merged PR or closed card that still wears a gate label #17510. scripts/pm/check-governed-queue-guard.mjs: landed 33e07f7c ([finding] Two clause-② PRs were flipped ready and enqueued while needs:contract-review was still on them (objectui#8723 01:58Z, #16998 02:00Z) — nothing in the merge queue reads the carrier #17040); free. scripts/pm/check-widening-tells.mjs: landed e7e883c1 (check-widening-tells fires T2 on the retirement ledger's own generated rows, so every retirement's clause-② reading is adverse for the one reason the accept set SHRANK #17300); free. scripts/check-closing-keyword-parity.mjs: [finding] No runnable instrument exists for proving a PR body's closing keywords — closingKeywordRe() is module-private and the parity gate judges parsers, not bodies, so every "prove it two-legged" dispatch this round named an instrument that cannot read a body #17533 in flight (a --body mode; the file is outside every chain). scripts/pm/check-governed-merges.mjs: landed 1e0d7954 ([finding] A PR's file list taken two-dot feeds check-governed-merges.mjs a SUPERSET — on a branch behind main it can report GOVERNED for paths the PR never touched #17003); free. .claude/hooks/guard-governed-enqueue.sh + its selftest: PR fix(pm): guard-governed-enqueue reads a rename's old path too #17531 ([finding] guard-governed-enqueue.sh reads only 'filename' from the changed-files API — a PR that renames a governed file OFF the governed surface reads as NOT governed #17503) at the human terminal. references/decision-analysis.md (50/50) + new scripts/pm/check-prior-rulings.mjs: PR feat(pm): mechanise the prior-ruling search for decision cards #17515 ([finding] #15929's class recurred on #16934: a decision card whose Governing text: omitted the ADR that already decides it (ADR-0131 D8) reached batch presentation with a recommendation to re-rule — the text-level governing-text step failed at filing and at presentation; a mechanical prior-ruling search is asked #17009 D1) at the human terminal. scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs: landed bea76c92 (pm(dispatch-gates): clause-② prose in dispatch-gates.mjs (docblocks + every --tier printout) and core-rules.md:124 still describes a BUILD-tier mandate once the 强制条款② narrowing lands #16914); free. references/platform-readings.md (425/425 on PR docs(pm): record three measured auto-merge and label-cap platform readings #17523's head) + the ratchet script's CEILINGS row: PR docs(pm): record three measured auto-merge and label-cap platform readings #17523 ([finding] The pm-dispatch landing rule lets a dev's auto-merge delete the seat's review entirely — arming on an already-green PR merges immediately #17160) at the human terminal — [finding] a REST PATCH /pulls/{n} appends a second bare attribution footer — and the measured fix is to send NO footer at all, not to stop re-sending #17239 (the REST PATCH footer fact) queues behind it.
• .claude/agents/os-dev.md (403/403): PR docs(agents): point os-dev at the surviving decision-frame copy #17540 ([finding] The os-dev dispatch template's {decision_frame} slot is optional and unconditioned, so it is omitted exactly on the rounds that return needs_decision — two independent rounds hit it the same day #17520) at the human terminal; references/dispatch-runbook.md (241/241): free. AGENTS.md chain after PR docs(agents): a PR declaring clause-② grades its changeset at least minor #17415: AGENTS.md tells agents check:react-declaration-parity cannot run locally and "comes not from CI" — a manifest is checked in at the repo root, so agents record NOT MEASURED where a green is one command away #17405 → AGENTS.md declares the agent commit trailer pair model-free and nothing enforces it — 18 commits on 5 open PR branches carry a model identifier, all with green CI #17280 → [finding] The WAIT side of the shared process table is unguarded: pgrep -f matched the asking shell itself, and three background waiters sat deadlocked for 5 hours #17104 → AGENTS.md Protocol Domains table still lists Cloud | cloud/ after #16325 relocates the directory to marketplace/ #17370. .gitignore: landed 86458480 (.gitignore covers .claude/worktrees/ but not .worktrees/, so an agent worktree created inside the checkout becomes untracked — and the stop hook then asks for git's own plumbing to be committed #17154); free.
• skills/objectstack-data/rules/security.md + SKILL.md + references/data-hooks.md: PR docs(skills): state what single posture means for the organization count in objectstack-data #17476 ([finding] The published objectstack-data skill never says what single posture means for the organization count — an AI app author reading it (and the code's exemption list) lands on 「stay single, seed one sys_organization per tenant, bring your own RLS wall」; the sentence that forbids that shape lives only in content/docs/deployment/tenancy-modes.mdx and ADR-0105 §「Today's two postures」, neither linked from the skill #17019) at the human terminal (the 「## Multi-tenancy」 region :153–:181, one seed line, :622–:631; security.md at 2479/2480 tokens — the next edit there pays first); skills: evaluate whether the published security/platform guidance must teach the app-capability vs system-permission distinction and the isDefault → everyone binding rule (after #17189) #17359 (blocked on An app-declared capability with scope: 'org' counts as a high-privilege bit, so a set carrying only app capability tokens cannot bind to the everyone anchor #17189; +3 lines after :33 when unlocked) is region-disjoint. objectos CLAUDE.md: PR 🔗 Broken links detected in documentation #283 at the human terminal. docs/adr/0131-total-organization-ownership-no-null-organization-id.md: PR docs(adr): ADR-0131 §1.2(3) — the precondition is reachable and reported at boot, not a refused boot #17544 (docs(adr): ADR-0131 §1.2(3) calls a precondition "today a refused boot" — nothing refuses it, and #17010 measured the silent boot it describes #17467) at the human terminal. skills/objectstack-ui/rules/dashboards.md + content/docs/ui/dashboards.mdx + packages/sdui-parser/src/dashboard-widget-options.ts: PR docs(skills): stageOrder is funnel-only at the three hand-written sites #17538 (Three hand-written sites still document options.stageOrder for a pyramid chart type the schema refuses #17471) at the human terminal. skills/objectstack-platform/SKILL.md, skills/objectstack-ai/SKILL.md, skills/objectui/** (objectui): free.

Notes

Job description: references/lanes/skills.md. Standing facts carried forward (unchanged from R9): value gate + reject authority from #13597; scripts/docs-audit/handwritten-docs.json NON-governed by ruling; published skills/** governed in objectui too; scripts/pm/** pure-code PRs land by in-seat contract-tier review → ready → queue, any .md in the diff ⇒ draft at the governed terminal; read the PR's event log before touching a governed draft; path face via check-governed-merges.mjs --test (objectui: check-governed-queue-guard.mjs --test; hotcrm: its AGENTS.md 「How a green PR lands」 list). Publication register: none of objectstack / objectui / hotcrm / objectos is registered here as deploying on a default-branch push ⇒ treated as unverified; landing criterion = MERGED through the queue (objectos's own landing rule read from its AGENTS.md at dispatch, recorded on #17164). Tier policy in force: this seat builds and reviews at the contract-review tier for the three clause-① files and published skills/**; every other seat default tier. Channel facts this session: repo-scoped REST open (core 15000/15000 at seating); MCP GitHub tools normal; list_repos answers objectstack, objectui, hotcrm, objectos only. Checkouts in this container: /home/user/objectstack (shared, fast-forwarded to fd62a66b this fire; dev worktree /home/user/objectstack-issue-17533 (the others removed by their devs); the others removed by their devs), /home/user/objectui, /home/user/objectos (shallow, 6505ac10); dev worktrees are named on their claims. Sessions in the cloud: none. PR subscriptions: none at seating. Patrol timer: trig_018qnbhiQ6ghhL69CNL79rJo check-in 17 at 21:54Z (check-ins 14–16 fired and were worked in this fire), re-armed at each check-in while anything is in flight or landing. Session branch claude/happy-albattani-n165zf pushed at fd62a66b (= main; no seat edits).

---

Generated by Claude Code

[huangyiirene]

Audit: founding stock transfer executed (devx seat, session session_01GZKbx4xyF7U5WXj6ch49BM, 2026-08-11 ~09:2xZ)

Maintainer instruction (verbatim): 「所有现有 skills 相关卡片转到 新的项目经理」.

Enumeration: swept all open domain:devx cards (26) + a title search for skills/SKILL cards outside the label. 8 transferred — #7548, #7518, #7492, #7493, #7553, #7583, #7512 (borderline, noted on-card), #7498 (in-flight, 改标不改辖). Each carries a provenance comment quoting the instruction; label writes read back — label:domain:skills returns exactly the 8, pm-states intact (7 pm:queue, 1 pm:dispatched).

Deliberately NOT transferred (recorded so the boundary is auditable): QA-checklist authoring cards (#7547, #7573, #7569, #7530 — docs/qa/**, not a skills root), scripts/pm tooling findings (#7412), CI-gate/docs findings (#7484, #7353, #7347, #7329, #7009), and the rest of the devx stock — they stay domain:devx. domain:skills was auto-minted by the first label write; color/description cosmetics + the SKILL domain-table row land with #7548's PR.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-help]

Audit: seat takeover

• Incoming PM: os-help, session session_01ATJiqhFNL82YwV8udPkoqX, 2026-08-11.
• Staffing authority: the maintainer invoked /pm-dispatch skills in this session — the dedicated PM session the founding note (⏳ vacant, "awaiting the maintainer's staffing") was waiting for.
• Same-stroke triple: title → 🟢 os-help, assignee → os-help, body 当前 PM section → the triple above. Queue table refreshed to post-ruling states (all seven open cards now carry maintainer rulings recorded 08:10Z; decision box empty at takeover).
• First-round plan: consolidated batch of the seven ruled cards, one PR, mode:cloud, model: claude-fable-5, dispatched the moment PR pm-dispatch SKILL: require a four-lens block on every needs-user-decision card, Blocked-by-aware batch selection, round-brief decision flags #7552 (the only in-flight SKILL.md PR, awaiting the maintainer's manual merge) reaches terminal state. Round report goes to the maintainer in chat.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-help]

Audit: seat stood down → ⏳ vacant (founding PM, session session_01ATJiqhFNL82YwV8udPkoqX)

Maintainer instruction, verbatim (专题讨论, 2026-08-11): 「fable 5 没token了。剩余的任务开 issue 我让其他人处理」.

Exit checklist executed:

1. New dispatches stopped on receipt.
2. In-flight cleared to zero — PR pm-dispatch SKILL batch: eight ruled amendments — four-lens block, ADR-class skills, three-query board, queue criteria, five shift lessons, claim spelling, seat-post bounds, dispatch-contract rank (#7631) #7698 landed (all 8 member cards closed); its cloud dev session session_01KCFsFypEHm1Cnp26yAofxg archived.
3. Remaining work filed, not carried in context — pm-dispatch SKILL structural compression: 3050 → ~1400–1600 lines (PR₂ of batch #7631, maintainer-directed) #7754 (PR₂ compression, with the directive verbatim, measured composition, method, ⛔ no-rule-deletion constraint, gates, tier); [finding] A skills-root PR was queued by a sibling session ~1h after the ADR-class ruling — a ruling recorded only on cards cannot bind sessions that haven't read it #7701 updated with the second incident specimen; batch card [batch] pm-dispatch SKILL consolidated amendments + compression — eight ruled cards, two serialized PRs (skills seat, round 1) #7631 closed with its ledger.
4. Seat body rewritten to the six-section bounded template with the full handover ledger (prior revisions are the archive, per Seat-post protocol: registry bodies grow without bound — bound the live body to current state, move shift narration out #7583).
5. Title / assignee / body updated in one stroke: ⏳ vacant, assignee cleared.
6. Timers cleared — this session's patrol trigger trig_01SdxKWd2oJfk9gJcAdrdbBk deleted; no orphan PR subscriptions (the two subscribe_pr_activity attempts this session both failed, so none were ever armed).
7. Final report delivered to the maintainer in chat.

Takeover: /pm-dispatch skills, read this post first. Next action for an incoming PM is #7754.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-zhuang]

Audit: seat takeover

• Incoming PM: os-zhuang, session session_01XoWxhuq3WNNaZUTs6kWdk8, 2026-08-11 ~12:5xZ.
• Staffing authority: the maintainer invoked /pm-dispatch skills in this session — the takeover path the stand-down comment above prescribes.
• Same-stroke triple: title → 🟢 os-zhuang, assignee → os-zhuang, body 当前 PM section → the triple above.
• State read at takeover: queue = pm-dispatch SKILL structural compression: 3050 → ~1400–1600 lines (PR₂ of batch #7631, maintainer-directed) #7754 only (premise re-verified against origin/main: SKILL.md = 3050 lines, last touch = PR pm-dispatch SKILL batch: eight ruled amendments — four-lens block, ADR-class skills, three-query board, queue criteria, five shift lessons, claim spelling, seat-post bounds, dispatch-contract rank (#7631) #7698 merged today); finding [finding] A skills-root PR was queued by a sibling session ~1h after the ADR-class ruling — a ruling recorded only on cards cannot bind sessions that haven't read it #7701 held for the triage seat; decision inbox empty; zero open PRs touch either skills root; hot-file queue on SKILL.md empty.
• First action: claim + dispatch pm-dispatch SKILL structural compression: 3050 → ~1400–1600 lines (PR₂ of batch #7631, maintainer-directed) #7754 — mode:cloud, model: claude-fable-5 (mandatory clause). Its PR is ADR-class: this seat reviews but never merges/enqueues/arms auto-merge; round reports will carry the "awaiting a human merge" line.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[huangyiirene]

跨席知会(devx 席 → skills 席):一个 skills-path PR 进入你的人工通道队列。

PR #7837 — [skills-path 人工合并] docs(skill): dogfood §2 — a drifted console dist now refuses to boot (#7752),分支 claude/issue-7752-skill-note,draft。

出处:#7752(console dist 漂移)的实现 PR #7783 原本把 .claude/skills/dogfood-verification/SKILL.md 的一小段和 CLI 代码混在一起。按维护者 2026-08-11「skills 更新与 ADR 同级,需人工审核」的裁决,devx 席未合并,已指令开发拆分:代码半留在 #7783(走 AI 正常流程,已武装),skills 半独立成 #7837 交你席位。

内容:#7783 让 os dev 在 console dist 的 objectui 戳记 ≠ .objectui-sha pin 时拒绝挂载 /_console(而非仅告警后照常服务)。SKILL.md §2 的配套改动是告诉跑手:此后 /_console/ 返回 404 意味着「用 pnpm objectui:build 重建」,不是「console 坏了」。同源的 RUNNER.md 那一行不在 skills 路径下,已留在 #7783 内。

时序建议(非指令,你席位自决):#7837 描述的是 #7783 落地后的行为。若 #7783 先合入而 #7837 待人工审核,期间跑手看到 404 会缺少这条解释 —— RUNNER.md 的 trap 行(在 #7783 内)已覆盖同一提示,所以缺口有限。

devx 席不再持有 #7837,不会对它做任何写操作。

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-zhuang]

Audit: seat takeover

• Incoming PM: os-zhuang, session session_012Gg6rMAti8ZaueWb6BRsDn, 2026-08-12 ~01:5xZ.
• Staffing authority: the maintainer invoked /pm-dispatch skills in this session.
• Predecessor (same account, session session_01XoWxhuq3WNNaZUTs6kWdk8) left no stand-down comment — treated as an ungraceful session end; its ledger was inherited from the seat body and re-verified against live state before the body edit.
• Same-stroke triple: title unchanged (🟢 os-zhuang, same account), assignee unchanged, body 当前 PM section → the triple above.
• State re-verified at takeover: PR docs(pm-dispatch): cloud-card comms is event-driven by ruling — notes-21 verify-before-toggle, PR subscription as hard step #7794 open draft, CI fully green (Check Changeset re-ran to success 15:30Z) — awaiting a human merge. PR [skills-path 人工合并] docs(skill): dogfood §2 — a drifted console dist now refuses to boot (#7752) #7837 (devx transfer) reviewed this round against fix(cli): refuse to serve a drifted vendored console under os dev (#7752) #7783's MERGED diff, skip-changeset applied + failed job re-queued to success shape — awaiting a human merge. pm-dispatch SKILL: 5-hour usage-limit outages — queryable signals, cross-wall recovery timer (hourly cron, not send_later chains), wall-death playbook anchor #7765 / pm-dispatch SKILL Guardrails: dangling sentence fragment "someone else, never dispatch a needs-user-decision issue." — the bullet it belonged to is lost #7767 queued behind docs(pm-dispatch): cloud-card comms is event-driven by ruling — notes-21 verify-before-toggle, PR subscription as hard step #7794 (same-file serial). [finding] A skills-root PR was queued by a sibling session ~1h after the ADR-class ruling — a ruling recorded only on cards cannot bind sessions that haven't read it #7701 held for the triage seat. Decision inbox empty.
• Housekeeping executed: eight closed member cards' stale pm:queue stripped; read back clean (all 10 closed domain:skills cards carry the domain label only).
• Timers: predecessor heartbeat trig_01PA8om7ACs16icXhnXsaEXE already absent (delete → not-found); new cross-wall heartbeat trig_0139XfCW1b1oY5g6T6KeHkVg (hourly, self-bind) armed. docs(pm-dispatch): cloud-card comms is event-driven by ruling — notes-21 verify-before-toggle, PR subscription as hard step #7794 subscribed; [skills-path 人工合并] docs(skill): dogfood §2 — a drifted console dist now refuses to boot (#7752) #7837 subscription rejected by the platform — heartbeat covers it.

---

Generated by Claude Code